A study recently came out by the Pew Internet and American Life Project, which said that, contrary to popular belief, Internet use is not linked to isolation, but rather is helpful in creating more diverse social networks.
I think that we can all agree that Facebook, Twitter, and the myriad other social networking sites out there increase the size of our networks, and increase the diversity of people we know.
However, it is a stretch to say that they create deeper relationships (which the study does not claim, but people seem to be jumping to that conclusion) or that the relationships are even the same.
In fact, the study says that our “core” networks, the people we can talk to about very important issues in our lives, have actually shrunk.
The 2008 survey of 2,512 adults did find that Americans’ core discussion networks — that group of people you count on being able to confide in — has gotten smaller in the past two decades. It’s down, on average, to about two people instead of three. They’ve also become less diverse because they contain fewer friends and more family members.
From Yahoo! News
I think the new normal we are entering into is one where we are becoming stretched thin because of the over-emphasis on utilizing technology alone to interact with people.
Author Shane Hipps says this in his book, Flickering Pixels (which I highly recommend for anyone interested in the intersection of technology and faith):
“Our nomadic life is a strange one. We drift and journey alone. However, because we are constantly bumping up against digital avatars and acquaintances, we are hardly aware of our isolation. Electronic technology can fragment us even as we pursue connection.”
We are unaware of our true isolation because we are constantly coming into contact with something that, by itself, cannot serve as a replacement.
I am not saying that online community or connections are invalid. Quite the opposite. The study proves that people in fact grow and diversify their community through the use of online tools. I am highly in favor of this! In fact, I think that everyone should utilize technology to do just this.
However, I think that it must be a compliment to physical interaction and community. We cannot become so reliant on technology (whether that is the internet, phones, or whatever may come) to keep us together that we become disconnected physically.
Thoughts? Do you feel more isolated than before you started using social networking? How has your “core” group improved or deteriorated?
Category: Internet Campus, Thoughts on Ministry
2 Comments »